Total Pageviews

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

(old)Days of Re"SEARCH"


In Post- independent India Development has become a catchword to gain public support for resource redistribution. Under the leadership of influential national leaders like first Indian Prime Minister Jawharlal Nehru, state initiated resource extraction and developmental activities like steel plants construction, mineral extraction, dams’ construction. As the Indian citizens had immense belief in the new Indian leadership and democracy, the process of resource redistribution through land acquisition and displacement of people from their resources were easier. The national leadership also firmly believed in the existing theories of economic development and social development through industrialization[1]. Economic planning and nationalization of resources were part of the dream to become a developed country following the paths of then well-developed socialist countries. The theoretical understanding of the process of economic development was actually evolving during that time period. As Indian planners tried to make Indian economy self sufficient as well as planned one, they did not change some of the fundamental colonial powers that the state was privileged with. Legislations that established state control over the natural resources and formalization of the eminent domain kind of principles were accepted as part of the development strategy. Colonial state government has institutionalized the forceful acquisition of land on the basis of the Land Acquisition Act 1894 and the government in post-independent India also continued to invoke these kinds of colonial legislations. Hence the emerged democratic structure resulted in a State-centered property right regime in case of common resources. Forest resources, minerals, rivers and all such natural resources also came under the state ownership.  This facilitated the resource redistribution under the industrialization-led development process which basically aimed at the large scale resource extraction to make efficient usage of natural resources. This reinstated the state power over community resources and the traditional forest dwellers like tribal population started loosing their rights over such resources. Before colonial legislation of reserving the forests under state ownership, tribal people used to co-exist with forest and its ecosystems. They preserved those as their community resources as they had informal and traditional community rights over their local resources. In some of the primitive tribal areas, still they do not have the individual property rights. Moreover the ownership over resources, tribals protect their resources due to their unique value frameworks in which they assign metaphysical significance for the natural resources. Indigenous communities used to worship nature and they consider their resources as divine.  As the property rights removed from the traditional forest dwellers, their resource ownership and livelihood options started getting challenged. Forest departments were given the authority to safeguard the forest resources. Their initial efforts were to remove the inhabitants and adivasis (indigenous people) from their resources and land, despite the fact that tribal people’s co-existence with forest for decades substantiates the sustainable community management of resources. Land acquisitions took place in the forest lands for the massive power generation through hydro-electrical projects, dams construction, minerals extraction and steel and iron manufacturing etc forced the traditional forest dwellers to move out of their resources. As the tribals were no more the legal owners of the land (where they were living for generations) their displacements from those resource-rich lands were easy.

Till liberalization of the economy, most of the development projects took place under the authority of public sector undertakings. After economic reforms in 1991 most of these projects got established under private companies and state's role changed to that of facilitator of such industrial projects. Hence the nature of resource extraction and the distribution of its benefits changed. Market got an important role in materializing industrial expansion using the unemployed resources including minerals. Regulations and controls over the resource extraction got liberalized. Investor friendly policies and investment facilitation became the primary interest of the governments. Ultimately, on the one hand people who got affected from such projects got worse off and on the other hand the ‘market preserving federalism’ as the outcome of liberalized open national economy resulted in the fierce competition among states to attract new investors. These aggravated the conflict between state governments and communities who depend on their local resources for livelihood. 

         The institutions generated by colonial rulers were not intended to protect the resources but meant to facilitate their industrial resource extraction. A comparative assessment of community ownership regime before the natural resources got nationalized and state-ownership regime substantiate the fact that state defined property rights didn’t help to preserve the forest resources as expected. Based on the policies initiated during colonial time period, forest department constituted for the protection of state's property right over natural resource in the post-independent era. Failure of state in protecting forest resources from encroachers, timber merchants and pouchers, as well as the injustice done towards the tribal and non-tribal forest dwelling classes along with the change in theoretical understandings about property right and open access problem of community resources reflected in the new policies like FRA 2006. This theoretical as well as policy level realization about the significance of forest dwellers in protecting the resources and their interdependence with their surroundings led to the Forest Rights Act 2006.  The biggest FDI proposal India has ever got was the POSCO FDI proposal signed in 2005. As FRA came into existence by 2006, POSCO land acquisition that included forest land was expected to fulfill the FRA criterion. As the policy initiative was to ensure that the rights of forest dwelling class of people is not getting violated and that their rights over resources are respected in case of resource redistribution for any developmental activity. Even then in case of forest clearance for the project, a clear cut institutional failure happened in POSCO case and the role assigned to local people got discarded in the whole process. Theory and policy making are complementary to each other, but while implementing the policies institutional barriers and functional problems cause a wide realization gap. This realization gap cause further deviations in the integration of research and policy making. This empirical analysis will help to assess the gap that exists between policies and practice in development; and to understand what prevents the research understandings from materializing and benefiting the process of development.

Theoretical understanding leading to policy measures
Environmental sustainability and the externalities of industrialization got the attention of policy makers and the result was the establishment of a nodal agency of the central government of India which is primarily intended for the conservation of the country's natural resources and for the prevention and abatement of pollution. This is the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF). MoEF established initially as National Council for Environment Policy and Planning within the Department of Science and Technology, following the 1972 United Nations Conference on the Human Environment in Stockholm. Later on MoEF has been given a prominent role in the national policy making and currently environmental clearances are crucial for any industry to be established. Importance given to sustainability and environmental protection in policy making is the direct result of new findings in development theory that expanded the meaning of development to a broader sense of sustainable development that enhances people to expand their opportunities. Few of the policy developments are explained here.

1. Forest Rights Act 2006 (FRA)
FRA enacted “to recognize and vest the forest rights and occupation in forest land in forest dwelling scheduled Tribes and other forest dwellers who have been residing in such forests for generations but whose rights could not be recorded, and also forest rights on ancestral lands and their habitat were not adequately recognized in the consolidation of state forests during the colonial period as well as in independent India resulting in historical injustice to the forest dwelling scheduled tribes and other traditional forest dwellers[2] who are integral to the very survival and sustainability of the forest system.” FRA ensures the rights of forest dwellers as individuals who use the resources as well as the communities that co exist with the given environment. FRA recognizes village level local governance bodies (Gram Sabhas[3]) as the guardians of their ecosystems. It laid down clear procedures to verify these claims and acknowledges community's right to take free, informed decision about giving consent to govern the ecosystems. If the forest land needs to be diverted for some industrial or other development purpose then the permission or agreement of these forest dwellers is essential according to the FRA. Hence their rights over their ancestral land for which they may or may not have records of legal ownership are recognized as their own land and land acquisition can happen only with the consent of the forest dwellers and further, all such acquisitions must be adequately compensated for.

2. Environmental Clearance
MoEF gives two clearances for developmental initiatives  – one for using forests under the Forest Conservation Act 1980 and another under Environment Protection Act – called the Environmental clearance. Forest Conservation Act 1980 restrains the use of forest lands for non forest purposes. Forest clearance from central government is needed for any project to start in forest land according to this. According to the Ministry of Environment & Forests (MoEF) “The basic objective of the Act is, to regulate the indiscriminate diversion of forest lands for non-forestry uses and to maintain a logical balance between the developmental needs of the country and the conservation of natural heritage.” State government has to get approval from central government to use reserved forest land for any non forest purpose and state government cannot lease forest land to any private parties that are not controlled or managed by government. The Environment (Protection) Act (EPA) was enacted in 1986 with the objective of providing protection and improvement of the environment. EPA empowers the government to make rules to regulate environmental pollution, by stipulating the ambience standards setting maximum limits on the discharges of pollutants into of the environment - air, water, and soil. After FRA came into existence the ministry in 2009, made its clearance process comply with the Forest Rights Act (FRA) and demanded approval from village councils before permitting mining in the forest area.

3. Environment impact assessment
The term Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) refers to the anticipation of various impacts a project will have on the environment and the local community. It is a decision making tool, which guides decision makers in taking appropriate decisions prior to sanctioning clearance. The
EIA Notification falls within the umbrella act – The Environment Protection Act, 1986. Environmental impact assessment ensures public participation in the decision process. Public consultation in the regulatory process is expected to help the decentralization of power also. Public hearing is an opportunity for the local people to express their concerns regarding the impacts of the proposed project, which also make the development process more democratic at the ground level. EIA is a pre-requisite for obtaining environmental clearance.

4. Rehabilitation

People's opposition to mega projects that displace them and negatively affect their livelihoods and living standards intensified following the lack of identification of people's right in decision making. Communities that tried to oppose such projects were blamed for acting against national interest and their grievances were not taken into account properly. People who got affected by land acquisition and other negative externalities of proposed projects failed to get any identification from state authorities. These conflicts got intensified during the nineties after liberalization. As land acquisition became a grave issue in the process of development, rehabilitation and resettlement policies enacted. National Rehabilitation and Resettlement Policy, 2007 aimed at ensuring rehabilitation and resettlement of persons affected by the acquisition of land towards projects described as serving a public purpose or involuntary displacement caused due to any other reason. But Rehabilitation policy 2007 failed to ensure a proper rehabilitation scheme in the system and the grievances of the project affected people has not got addressed properly. As people had serious issues with the existing model of resource redistribution and land acquisition, most of the projects proposed even after the implementation of NRRP 2007 faced public protest. Especially in mining and mining related projects, the dissidence from the part of indigenous people mostly tribal people in the forest areas was very evidential.  As the central government realized the importance of local people's support for any the successful working of any development project, attempts for a new rehabilitation policy started from the government's side. Draft of National Land Acquisition and Rehabilitation & Resettlement Bill, 2011 is an attempt to balance the need to facilitate land acquisition for various public purposes including infrastructure development, industrialization and urbanization, and to address the concerns of farmers and those whose livelihoods are dependent on the land being acquired. This draft Bill is proposed with primacy over other specialized legislations like laws for highways, SEZ's, railways etc. This law prohibits private companies from purchase of multi-cropped irrigated land for public purposes. Social Impact Assessment (SIA) is made mandatory as per the draft bill, which ensures that the Gram Sabha is consulted and the SIA is made available for the public scrutiny. This new Bill is meant to ensure “a humane, participatory, informed, consultative and transparent process”; and guarantees that the cumulative outcome of compulsory acquisition should be that affected persons become partners in development.


POSCO Project: The biggest FDI and the strongest protest

POSCO signed the memorandum of understanding (MoU) with Orissa state government in June 2005, to set up a 12 million tons per annum (MTPA) green field steel plant near Paradip, Jagatsinghpur District, Orissa, with an estimated investment of $12 billion USD (Rs.52,000 crores) which is the largest ever Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) initiative since Indian economy liberalized in 1991. This proposed steel plant needs to acquire land from eight villages in three gram Panchayats, namely Dhinkia, Nuagaon and Gadakujang in Jagatatsinghpur district of Orissa. The plant would require a total of 1620.496 hectares of land of which 1253.225 hectares is forest land. Official statistics show that only 438 acres of the 4,000 acres required for the POSCO site are private land, the rest being government land, recorded as ‘under forest’ but most of this land is under betel, cashew and other cultivation for years and the local people have a right in this land as per the Forest rights Act. Local inhabitants whose land was earmarked for the project and whose livelihood was going to be adversely affected due to the displacement started their protests from the time when the MoU signed. Various groups like POSCO Pratirodh Sangram Samiti (PPSS) started forming from August 2005 onwards and they use different strategies of protest against the project including the blockage of the entry of any government or POSCO official into three (Dhinkia, Gada Kujanga and Nuagaon) of the nine villages earmarked for the POSCO project.
Opposition to the POSCO project has been continuing for the last 7 years. People and groups that oppose the project raise various issues regarding the POSCO project including the “subversion of state’s authority and sovereignty for POSCO’s benefits”(MZPSG's report (2010) http://miningzone.org), impoverishment and loss of livelihood threat of the villages that face displacement for the project and other socio-economic issues. The current local economy is a well-flourished agrarian one, which provides good living standards for the residents; they prefer it over the new one promised by POSCO. Justice of trading off the rights of some people for the so called “national interest” which is a claim that is not substantiated or clearly defined yet is continuously questioned by local people. They demand the state government to enter into discussions with them about the project implementation and land acquisition for the project. State authorities failed to respond to their demands and state and central government still try to initiate the project there against the wish of the local people. As POSCO investment is considered by the authorities as a green signal for the “economic development” of the state and also country, the local people who face the threat of displacement consider it as a devastating change that will cause destitution for them. This conflict of interests of government and local people prevented the initiation of the project even after seven years. In between, the project has got all the approvals from authorities like that of Forest clearance, Environmental clearance and sanction to start with land acquisition. But it is already exposed that most of these clearances POSCO has got without fulfilling the essential criteria and state government functioned in a completely biased way to retain the investment.


Development: how it differ for government and local people

As per the MoU between government of Odisha and POSCO, the benefits offered includes road and rail that link the steel plant with the port, township made for the employees of POSCO, power plant made for meeting the needs of POSCO steel plant and the full project (including iron ore mining, steel plant including captive port) which is claimed to create an additional employment of 50,000 person years annually for the next 30 years and Rs.20 billion of additional output for Odisha. Interestingly, in the NCAER cost-benefit report[4] they describe the employment and output multiplier of iron-ore rather than that of steel that will be produced in the plant. As a result, separate measures for the steel plant are not available. Hence the steel plant that is proposed to begin in Jagatsighpur is expected to contribute its share in output multiplier of 2.36 and employment multiplier of 0.69. This means that 0.69 man-year of employment will be created for every Rs.1 lakh output of crude steel. Hence, as per the NCAER report the iron ore project would contribute 1.3 per cent to Odisha’s State Gross Domestic Product (or SGDP) by 2016-17.

Most importantly, these figures do not talk about what the 52000 crore steel plant project itself can bring into the economy, but includes the iron ore mining that will constitute 600 million tonnes of iron ore of an average Fe content of 62%, to meet the requirements of the proposed Steel Project of 12 million tonnes per annum. Hence these numbers can't be inclusive of all the costs that the society has to bear and environmental degradation that'll happen due to the steel plant. From the point of view of the potentially displaced and project affected people, who will directly lose their land and livelihoods for the steel plant the benefits that are offered according to the MoU are “(viii) for rehabilitation of displaced families, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Package would be implemented as per prevailing guidelines and practices”. Even after the protest and opposition from the people regarding the land acquisition and displacement, government didn't implement the rehabilitation and resettlement guidelines that exist in the state and central level. Later, the rehabilitation package that was announced by POSCO following the first meeting of Rehabilitation and Periphery Development Advisory Committee (RPDAC) which was held five years after the signing of the MoU offered compensation package of Rs 17 lakh per acre for private land, Rs 11,500 per decimal of betel vine and Rs 2 lakh per prawn farm to be acquired for the plant. According to this package “Altogether 718 families which included 466 original families and 252 extended families, would be affected in the project. While each
original family will get a 443 sq feet house on 10 decimal land in the rehabilitation colony, the extended families will get 10 decimal land and Rs 1.66 lakh towards compensation. This apart, a member of each nucleus family will get a job”[5]. This package got rejected by the local farmers and other villagers. These farmers and others who are dependent on the betel vine economy can earn more income by continuing their current livelihoods[6]. As per the MZPSG's (Mining Zone People’s Solidarity Group) report[7], “the average net income yield per decimal of betel vine ranged between Rs.37,000/ decimal (at Rs.0.57/leaf) and Rs.40,000 (at Rs.0.60/leaf). The minimum recorded per decimal yield was Rs.32,000, and the maximum per decimal yield recorded was Rs. 50,000 ”(MZPSG Report; Iron and Steel: The POSCO-India story, 2010, pp. 35). Hence the compensation that is offered for their betel vine yards that can earn them annual incomes of around Rs 40000 seems negligible for the local people. And the report of the Committee Constituted to investigate into the proposal submitted by POSCO India Pvt. Limited for establishment of an Integrated Steel Plant and Captive Port in Jagatsinghpur District, Orissa steel plant will displace and reallocate these farmers to utter destitution without any such livelihood option. Betel vine yards can accommodate people of varying age groups into employment due to the nature of work that its cultivation offers. Landless workers also prefer betel vine economy over the industrial one offered by POSCO. MZPSG's report concludes that “paan kheti employment was preferable to industrial employment, since they were able to find work regularly and at wage rates far higher than the Orissa minimum wage” (MZPSG report, 2010, pp.35). The fallacy of employment generation by POSCO project is questioned in the MZPSG's report. The employment multiplier for iron ore mining and steel production as well as the employment generation proposed in the NCAER report is questionable because the projected calculations in the report are on the basis of a strong and false assumption that the sectoral linkages would remain unchanged for the duration of the project – which is around 30 years. Moreover, the potential employment is predicted based on unrealistic assumptions about technology and prices. While in reality, technological changes in the mining and related sectors have been labor displacing and this is not taken into account. Further, the arbitrary assumption of constancy of price of steel makes the employment predictions less reliable. The potential employment opportunities generated through backward linkages by POSCO are also low since the NCAER report notes that “POSCO‐India assumes that imported procurement is 65 per cent of total input materials" and hence only the remaining 35% of its inputs will be sourced from India[8]. Moreover, baseline figures of current livelihoods in the three Gram Panchayats are not taken into account in the current analysis. Hence, as the MZPSG's report suggests, the benefits that can be brought to the national and state economy need to be reviewed after considering all these flaws with the current cost-benefit analysis done. Both NCAER and MZPSG's reports deal with the whole project including the steel plant, captive port and the mining. As this dissertation mainly takes into account the steel plant project that is proposed in Jagatsighpur, further analysis will be limited to this dimension of the problem, although the broad background of whole project will be taken into account. On the basis of the limitations of the reports pointed above, the claims of massive employment generation and growth prospects that will be generated from POSCO project are often exaggerated or unfound.

In what follows, the impact on the local economy and people is deliberated further. As it is already mentioned, local farmers and daily workers can't get improved average incomes due to the project. The compensation offered to the betel vine farmers is much lesser compared to their life time earnings from the current agrarian economy. In the existing local economy the landless daily wage laborers get work regularly at a wage rate far higher than the stipulated minimum wage in Odisha45. If the affected sections from these categories of employment were to accept employment in POSCO steel plant as an alternative, then they would become contract workers, which are characterized by no job security, low wages, gender inequities in pay, and sexual harassment46. Existing local economy ensure steady agrarian employment due to the nature of betel vine cultivation, which is far more protective in social terms also compared to the informal work in the industrial sector. There is a likelihood of the local workers being replaced by other migrant workers and there is no protection against such a substitution. In mining sector, level of mechanization is highly increasing and such technological changes could also displace workers and there is no protection against such displacement. Moreover, in addition to the point already made that the incomes of the people are likely to suffer a decline; past experiences suggests a possibility of an increase in the average household expenditures following the implementation of the project. This is due to the intricate links between the social, economic and ecological aspects of life amongst these communities. Firstly, the affected people can no more have access to farming and other community commons they used to have access to prior to the project, they may have to depend on the markets to meet these demands. This will imply additional expenditures on their daily consumption of various goods like water, firewood, vegetables etc. Secondly, the project is likely to cause a collapse of current agrarian economy which would definitely let them earn a higher income under relatively healthy working conditions compared to smelting and other steel processing activities in a steel plant which will involve greater occupational risks without any occupational risk compensations. Further, other comforts of life that are anticipated as a consequence to modern development like electricity, telephone connectivity, modern health care, education systems etc., are not assured by the company or the government to the affected people. Rail- road connectivity offered and power generation ensured in the project is only for the benefit of steel plant and these benefits do not accrue to the local people. This ‘investment led development’ does not ensure any improvement of well-being for the local people. This causes strong opposition from potentially project affected communities.

Rehabilitation is not accepted as an agreeable alternative for the current local economy and the evidence prove that POSCO project does not work as a “development project” for the potentially affected people. Considering this fact, any policy measure to improve the rehabilitation and resettlement can't work here. A very important observation needs to be done here is that, even the existing rehabilitation policy does not allow displacement of people without their permission and agreement. But this policy norm gets violated easily. The main reason for such an inherent contradiction in policy and practice is the structural flexibility in governance system to overcome protective policies with more authoritative growth intended policies. This becomes easier in the current situation where dominant regime of market led growth is generally accepted as a national policy. The social reaction and defects with the current model of development get noticed by the activists and academicians, and the efforts to include those social externalities into account are already taking place. Policy implications of such efforts also come out as in the case of FRA 2006. But the realization gap that distances such policies and research from practice and more importantly from the real outcomes needs to be analyzed. Otherwise all the research that take place in development theory will go in vain. The gap between realization and policy making cause further defects in the theoretical understanding of the developmental problems, if the realization gap is not identified fully.

Realization Gap

In POSCO case, property rights are clearly defined. Non-forest private land demarcated for land acquisition clearly belongs to private owners. Forest land comes under the theoretical introspection of definition of property rights. Before 2006 FRA enactment, forestland defined as under state ownership. Environmental Impact Assessment is a legislation meant for the protection of environment and local communities that get affected by a project. Before a project obtains statutory environmental clearance from the Ministry of Environment and Forest (MoEF), it has to produce an EIA. EIA notification requires a public hearing to be done “in a systematic, time bound and transparent manner ensuring widest public participation at the project site(s) or in its close proximity". To conduct this mandatory public hearing, a notification has to be given in all the major local and national daily news-papers one month before the public hearing. The EIA reports must be provided to the concerned Panchayats. A Gram Sabha must be organized where the EIA report has to be discussed and based on the majority opinion, a decision has to be arrived at about the project in question. The Public hearing is meant to listen to the views of the community. It’s a forum where the local people could air their doubts, grievances and problems pertaining to the project. It is also a platform where opposing interest groups can freely express their views. Public hearing is the one and only participatory forum people have, to express their views on the development project in case of non-forest land. State pollution control board is the institution that needs to conduct the public hearing for the environmental clearance. In most of the cases public hearings are conducted in a haphazard manner and are thus reduced to a mere formality[9].

In POSCO EIA on 15 April 2007, a joint public hearing as per the Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification 2006[10] was conducted for the captive port and first phase of the steel plant. Public hearing conducted by the OSPCB (Orissa state pollution Control Board) at Kujanga which is 15 Km away from the project affected area. Not at project site and not even at a “close proximity”. This clearly is a serious violation of the objective of the public hearing that seeks to ensure widest public participation. Public hearings are subject to complete deviation from the spirit with which it is prescribed in the EIA notification. In various cases, people's dissent and resistance ends up in turmoil and law and order problems which then get reduced to conflicts between the state police and the protesters.  Authorities have often taken an investor friendly position rather than genuinely respecting the democratic deliberative mechanisms and people's verdict[11]. Local people can't be taken as a homogeneous group of protesters, some of them are ready to accept the compensation and support the development projects in the expectations of employment or good compensation and rehabilitation being offered than their prevailing living condition. Public hearing, if conducted in a free democratic environment can take into account all the concerns and demands of the people. EIA report for the captive port (at Jatadharmohan Creek, Paradeep in Orissa for supporting the 12 million tons per annum (MTPA) POSCO steel plant) prepared by National Institute of Oceanography (NIO) has been technically evaluated by Center for Science and Environment ( CSE). This port is meant to support the import of coal and iron ore and to export the finished steel products. Technical evaluation of the Marine Environmental Impact Assessment (MEIA) done by CSE points out many defects. First of all it is pointed out that the EIA for POSCO has been done without conducting any field study. This reveals the lack of credibility of the EIA report. The report does not deal with the impact of the project on Jatadhari River and its drainage pattern. Biodiversity of the area is not considered seriously which is  obvious from the fact that Olive Ridley Turtle, enlisted as endangered species in IUCN red data book is found in the areas proximate to the Gahirmatha Sanctuary which is located near the port and at the mouth of Devi River the olive turtles come for nesting. Measures ought to be taken to ensure that the raw materials such as iron ore, coal and steel products that will be transported and stored in the port do not give rise to fugitive dust causing air pollution. This aspect is also not mentioned in the official EIA report. Impact on livelihoods of people who depend on betel vineyard and cashew plantation as well as the fishing community is not discussed in the report. POSCO got the EIA done by National Institute of Oceanography and the EIA report which consists of such serious omissions, was the basis on which MoEF has given environmental clearance for the project. POSCO sought to get separate environmental clearances for steel plant and port. This will not give the details of cumulative environmental impact of these projects. POSCO prepared the EIA and applied for environmental clearance for 4 MTPY capacity steel plant only, while the land is demanded for 12 MTPY steel plant[12]. Total scale of project is almost equal to combined production capacity of 6 steel plants of India (Bhilai, Bokaro, Durgapur, Rourkela, Burnpur and Salem put together); even then POSCO got environmental clearance without doing a comprehensive environment impact analysis (EIA). They submitted a rapid EIA that also based on data on monsoon period for the port while data collection on monsoon period is prohibited by EIA notification. In the POSCO EIA public hearings are conducted under mostly unfavorable conditions for the public to participate freely. First of all, the draft EIA report was not available for the villagers before the POSCO public hearing. Heavy deployment of police of an estimated 1000 police were stationed at the venue of the public hearing days before the public hearing created a situation of panic among the people who resist the project . Deployment of police force creates a situation of anxiety and fear, rather than an atmosphere of peaceful public consultation especially because of the conflict in interest of the state and local people in the issue. Public consultation is prescribed for making the process more democratic while such intervention of force and atmosphere of coercion cause tension for the local people. Incidents like Kalinganagar and Nandigram[13] police firings already left an impression of state using repressive mechanisms to prevent public protest against industrial projects and its acquisition. The presence of platoons of policemen prior to the public hearing and the conduct of public hearing at Kujang which is almost 15 km away from the project site reinforced the fear that local people had. This was a major cause for the number of participants in the public hearing to be low. The purpose of conducting a public hearing itself was defeated due to such lacuna in handling public hearing by the authorities.

Forest rights Act is comparatively new legislation that formed after considering many historical facts and mistakes that happened during last decades towards the forest dwelling communities. Ecology and biodiversity are recognized in a broader framework which includes the forest dwelling communities too. The realization that is provided by the FRA is fact that tribals and the other forest dwelling communities are the integral part of the environment that meant to be protected by the former environment protection Acts. A shift in the policy making that reflected from the view of communitarian forest conservation ideas led to the legalization of the rights that the forest dwellers had on the land and ecology in which they were sustained on. Hence FRA is considered as a revolutionary Act that gave the local communities a say on the resources on which they were dependent on as well as co-existed with as the conservers. FRA seeks the permission of Gram sabhas to start land Acquisition in Forest land areas. According to Forest Conservation Act 1980, when projects fall within forestlands, prior clearance is required from relevant authorities. State governments cannot de-reserve any forestland or authorize its use for any non-forest purposes without approval from the Central government. POSCO got its final forest clearance from the MoEF on May 2nd 2011. Forest clearance needs to be in accordance with the forest conservation Act 1980 and the Forest Rights Act 2006. But POSCO got its dubious forest clearance from MoEF without clearing the confusions that aroused about FRA implementation in the process. Forest Rights Act with all the authority enforced in it for the empowerment and participation of people in the decision making process became merit less due to this act of MoEF. According to FRA provisions Gram Sabha is entitled to take a decision about the land acquisition proposal. But in POSCO case State government argued that the Palli Sabha(village council) meetings in which two village councils denied permission to land acquisition were not valid. Former Union Minister for Environment and Forests, Jairam Ramesh accepted the State government's claim that the two Palli Sabha resolutions were invalid as they were passed at meetings convened by the sarpanch without the authority of the gram Panchayat, they were not recorded in a book kept for the purpose, and they were signed by only 60-odd people in each of the villages. The forest clearance that was given to POSCO needs to be studied thoroughly to understand how the institutional provisions become ineffective under a situation of utter inequality of power. State government had a very significant role to play in the whole process. State government is supposed to implement the FRA and to ensure that the rights of forest dwellers are protected in the whole process of land acquisition for any non-forest purpose. In POSCO land acquisition case, Orissa State government had an active role in facilitating the project which is evidential from the MoU in which included the norm that, MoU, 6(xiii) “The Government of Orissa will assist the Company in obtaining all clearances, including forest and environment clearance and approval of the State Pollution Control Board, and the Ministry of Environment and Forest, Government of India under Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Environmental (Protection) Act, 1986 for opening up the iron ore mines, laying roads, constructing township etc.” State government's Act comes under questioning because POSCO Pratirodh Sangram Samiti (PPSS) alleged that the State government is deliberately showing only the signatures on the first page of the scanned document, while the hard copies of the resolutions show that 1,638 people signed the resolution of Dhinkia and 1,265 people signed the resolution of Gobindpur. Rather than rejecting the two Palli Sabha meetings that took place as invalid, state government didn't implement FRA in the area which is obvious from the state government saying that no Palli Sabha meeting was ever held otherwise. The resolutions sent by the two Palli Sabhas have been rejected by the state government on the grounds that the quorum was not met. However, the resolution sent by Orissa state government was signed by only 34 people, which is not valid under law because the gram sabha meeting for passing a resolution should be attended by at least two-thirds of a village’s adult population. This discrepancy demonstrates how there is a lack of standardized procedural neutrality in institutional functioning and how there is an inbuilt bias in institutional functioning towards private capital. Structure of the institution and the working of it are equally important as the policy making. FRA recognizes the rights of the forest dwellers and at least formally respects their right to take part in the decision making process in development. But by treating POSCO case as “a learning and evolving process” of FRA and by inconsistently rejecting community’s decisions where they went against the POSCO and by accepting decisions when favorable to POSCO, Mr.Jairam Ramesh has in effect redefined the role of the regulatory institutions in relation to the rights of the forest dwellers under the FRA passed by the parliament.

The MoEF/MoTA Committee (Three member subcommittee of Environment Ministry's "Committee to Study the Forest Rights Act" comprising of ArupjyotiSaikia, Ravi Rebbapragada and Ashish Kothari) visited the proposed plant site and did public consultation in Bhubaneshwar and had discussions with senior officials of the Orissa government. Their report which was submitted in August 2010 clearly states that contrary to what the district administration was, there were other Traditional Forest Dwellers (OTFDs) in the area. Committee report concludes that “Any work related to the project in this area is a violation of the FRA, and of the conditionality laid down by the MoEF in its forest clearance 29 December 2009”[14] Committee report recommended MoEF to “Ask the Orissa government to stop all such work till the required processes under the FRA are completed, and till and if Palli Sabha consent is obtained. And to withdraw the forest clearance provided in December 2009.”53 By July 29, 2010 Environment Ministry constituted a special four member Committee in order to investigate into the implementation of Forest Rights Act in and around the plant site and also to look into the status of implementation of the Rehabilitation and Resettlement package pertaining to the project. This committee was chaired by former Environment Secretary Meena Gupta. The Major part of the report of the committee went against the claims of the state government and found that the forest clearance was illegal and it recommended revoking the forest clearance given on December 2009. Sole member Meena Gupta submitted a dissenting report that contradicts these findings and recommendations. Meena Gupta agrees with the majority report recommending re- implementation of the Forest Rights Act in the region as the procedure for FRA has not been done properly. However, in her view, the environmental clearance need not be revoked; instead, additional conditions can be applied before the construction starts. Following this report Forest Advisory Committee recommended a temporary withdrawal of the forest clearance on the grounds of violations of FRA on November 19, 2010. But by January 31, 2011MoEF gave permission to go ahead with the project with the final clearance under the conditions. On February 21 Dhinkia Palli Sabha and on February 23 Gobindpur Palli Sabha convened and passed resolution rejecting consent for diversion of forest land.

In several POSCO project landmarked villages people claim that they had made both individual and community claims which were approved in their Gram Sabha resolutions which they had submitted to the concerned officials of the district administration. According to the Majority Report of the MoEF committee that was constituted to investigate into the proposal submitted by POSCO-India Pvt. Ltd. “On March 23, 2008 the PalliSabhas in the three GPs of Dhinkia, Nuagaon and Gadkujang formed forest rights committees with the exception of some villages, viz., Bhuyanpal and Noliasahi, where the said committees were formed later”. As per the FRA directives before processing applications for diversion of forest land for any non-forest purpose, the proposal should be accompanied by “A letter from each of the concerned Gram Sabhas, indicating that all formalities/processes under the FRA have been carried out, and that they have given their consent to the proposed diversion and the compensatory and ameliorative measures if any, having understood the purposes and details of proposed diversion” (exerted from MoEF circular issued on July 30, 2009 and August 3rd, 2009). While this legislation exists as such, POSCO project got the final forest clearance on Dec 29, 2009 without any such certificates being provided by the State government or by the concerned Gram Sabha, regarding either the completion of the Forests Rights Act process or the consent of the PalliSabhas to the diversion of forest land. As per the committee report “PalliSabhas of Dhinkia, Govindpur and Nuagaon met on Feb 5, Feb 6 and Feb 4th, 2010 respectively. They all passed similar resolutions rejecting diversion of forest land for establishing the POSCO steel plant, asserting their eligibility as other traditional forest dwellers (OTFDs) under the Forest Rights Act and invoking their powers under section 5 of the Act to protect forests, wildlife, biodiversity and their cultural and natural heritage”. Even after the Pallisabhas proclaimed their right to protect their forest ecosystem, state government sent their letter to MoEF stating that “no claims for settlement of rights from tribals and traditional forest dwellers have been received. Since no tribals or traditional forest dwellers are residing in the aforesaid area, the question of settlement of rights of tribal people /other traditional forest dwellers under the Forest Rights Act does not arise”. Hence what happened in this case is the denial of rights of people by circumventing through manipulations, the institutionalized guarantees to tribal populace.

Hence, the gap that exists between the policies and realizations makes the principles behind such policies as irrelevant and inactive. Most of the institutional mechanisms failed to work in the prescribed way in POSCO case. This empirical evidences need to be taken in to consideration while assessing the working of principles and in reaching an assessment of the development model. Prominent paradigm that prevails in the system influences the realized outcome to a great extent. Even though much legislation are there to protect the interests of people and environment, as in the POSCO case those legislations and institutional measures may not work properly and the outcome can be contrary to the principles that prevail . As Sen suggests in his Idea of Justice (2009) actual realizations and accomplishments needs to be focused in assessing the real impact of such arrangements that exists.

In the POSCO case, people's representation and democratic ways of opposition is ignored by the state and the central governments in favor of the development regime that supports private investment at any cost. Both environmental and social costs of the project are estimated as much higher when compared to the benefits, the project can bring to the economy. Even after the local self-governments (pallisabhas) expressed their dissent in diverting land for the project, central and state governments plan to go ahead with the project. This is a gross violation of the democratic rights and powers, thrust upon local governments as per the three-tier system of governance in India.

To reduce the gap existing in the integration of policy and practice
Policy making is more close to the academic understanding of development and the new conflicts arising out of current model of development, especially in terms of environmental and social sustainability. But policy enactment does not ensure the realization of its essence. As a result even the valuable understandings of research in development studies go in vain. Industrialization and high GDP generation is the widely accepted norm of development, without acknowledging the other factors like real human development through capability expansion, sustainability of the process of development and ultimately the well-being of people. Mainly politicians and government officials try to attain maximum investment and income generation in the economy which can be easily transformed to infrastructure and power sector expansion. This dominant stigma works against the true spirit of expansion of opportunities people actually have. Communities that get affected by these kinds of one sided policy decisions oppose such “developmental projects” and that result in strong protests from people which normally gets aggravated by the forceful land acquisition efforts from the part of state. Redefinition of property rights and community rights over forest resources and its significance in the preservation of natural resources was the result of integration of research into policy. But practice of the same needs rigid institutional set ups. Current institutions and institutional mechanisms are not efficient to implement the policy directives, when the dominant norm of development and industrial expansion comes in conflict with the real human development and rights protection (both civil rights and property rights). This can be resolved to a great extent if the power to take decisions about a new development project is shared with people more equally, especially with those who will get directly affected by the project. Under such a condition, policy implementation will be closely watched by local self governments with the decision making power they are assigned with.


[1] Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru himself proclaimed that “Bhakra is the new temple of resurgent India. It is the symbol of India’s progress.”In the case of Bhakra dam 7,206 families were affected comprising about 36,000 persons in 371 villages that were displaced and not properly resettled but then the spirit of nation building helped the government in pacifying those who has undergone displacement. Nehru said to the displaced persons of Hirakund Dam in 1948 that “If you are to suffer, you should suffer in the interest of the nation”
[2] “Other traditional forest dweller” means any member or community who has at least for 3 generations prior to
the 13th day of December, 2005 primarily resided in and who depended on the forest, or forest land for bona fide
livelihood needs.
[3] Means a village assembly which shall consist of all adult members of a village and in case of states having no
Panchayats, Padas, Todas and other traditional village institutions and elected village committees, with full and
unrestricted participation of women (FRA, 2006 chapter 1, Def: 2g)

[4] National Council for Applied Economic Research (NCAER) in 2007 done a cost‐benefit analysis of the POSCO project and submitted their report saying that “apart from representing the least cost technology, POSCO’s project would yield attractive returns. The economic impact of the project is estimated at USD 2.5 billion at the test discount rate of 12 per cent”. Odisha state government uses this report to justify the POSCO project and showcase that the project is essential for the state economy to develop.
[5] RPDAC declares compensation package for POSCO Project. July 8, 2010. Newkerala.com [UNI]
[6] P.p. 127. Report of the Committee Constituted to Investigate into the proposal submitted by POSCO India Pvt.
Limited for establishment of an Integrated Steel Plant and Captive Port in Jagatsinghpur District, Orissa
[7] The Mining Zone People’s Solidarity Group is an international research group focused on India, with core interests in new economic policy. They have done a comprehensive analysis of the POSCO project as well as a critical evaluation of NCAER cost-benefit report. Their report “Iron and Steel: The POSCO-India story” published in 2010 uses unconventional frameworks in the analysis. 
[8] Iron and steel: The POSCO India story.(2010) pp.41-46
[9] It is evidential in many cases like Vedanta project(REPORT OF THE FOUR MEMBER COMMITTEE FOR
INVESTIGATION INTO THE PROPOSAL SUBMITTED BY THE ORISSA MINING COMPANY FOR BAUXITE MINING IN
NIYAMGIRI. August 16, 2010 chaired by Dr N C Saxena), Jindal steel’s coal mining project in Chhattisgarh (Green
tribunal sets aside clearance granted to Jindal, The Hindu, 21 April, 2012) etc
[10] EIA notification by MoEF retrieved from http://envfor.nic.in/legis/eia/so1533.pdf
[11] Chaturvedi.R. (Oct.2004).Environmental Hearings: Participatory Forums or a Mere Procedure? Economic and
Political Weekly(39)42, 4616-4619.
[12] Report of the Committee Constituted to Investigate into the proposal submitted by POSCO India Pvt. Limited for
establishment of an Integrated Steel Plant and Captive Port in Jagatsinghpur District, Orissa Pp. 43
[13] Conflict between protesters and police men regarding the land acquisition process caused total of 28 deaths in
these places( 14 persons in Kalingnagar (January 2, 2006) and 14 persons in Nandigram died in Police firing on
March 14,2007). Police open fire at proteters, The Hindu,May 13,2010. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nandigram_violence
[14] Report of visit to Jagatsinghpur (site of proposed POSCO project), Orissa, 23-24 July 2010. MoEF/MoTA
Committee on Forest Rights Act Report

No comments: