Total Pageviews

Monday, June 28, 2010

Eviction of landless tribals from Land acquired for Vedanta Alumina Ltd., Lanjigarh Block, Kalahandi
district
Almost 64 landless Kondh households (Scheduled Tribes) of the Jaganathpur Village had been cultivating Khesara no 186 categorized as Revenue land for the last 30-40 years. Encroachment cases for the cultivation had been filed by the Revenue Department against many of these people. The encroachment notices show that these Scheduled tribe persons have been in physical possession of these lands for at least last seven to eight years. However, the tribals claim that even their forefathers were cultivating the land. Both as per the
principal of adverse possession and as per the section 7(a) of Orissa prevention of Land Encroachment Act, 1972, such land should have been settled with the landless persons to the extent of one standard acre (equivalent to 4.5 acres of uplands). The last revisional Survey and Settlement of Lanjigarh block took place in the late eighties, and the tribals claim that when they tried to get the land regularized in their names, they were asked to pay bribes up to Rs. 5000/- per acre, which they couldn’t afford. Even after the settlement, they have been trying to get the land regularized through revenue department, but have been asked for bribes by the Revenue department personnel. In 2003, instead of settling this land with the tribal cultivators cultivating these lands, the district administration summarily evicted these 64 families by force without any compensation, thereby taking away their main source of livelihoods. The land has been handed over by the district administration to Vedanta Alumina Ltd. for the construction of their rehabilitation colony. In law, this action violates not only the rule of adverse possession and section 7(a) of OPLE, 1972 but it also it violates the protection provided to the Scheduled tribes in Schedule V of the Constitution and the section 3(iii) of the OSATIP Regulations (1956) by turning scheduled tribes “effectively” landless. The section 3(iii) of OSATIP regulation (1956) provides a minimum benchmark of 2 acres of irrigated or five acres of unirrigated land for ownership by scheduled tribes before any land is their possession can be transferred. By not recognizing their cultivation rights and by evicting landless scheduled tribe persons from the land cultivated by them for generations, the provision is violated. Non-settlement of government land cultivated by them is one of the most common complaints by tribals. Regularization of encroachments invariably requires speed money, and those who can’t pay, don’t get their land regularized either during the settlements or through the revenue administration.

Dispossessed and displaced: A brief paper on tribal issues in Orissa
by
Kundan Kumar

I think i am not an economist..

Development is now more than an economist’s academic curiosity; is a challenge for the common man who fails to understand the complexities of gross capital formation or investment growth rate but loosing his farm land and livelihood for it and then waiting for inclusive development to improve his life some other day. As forced land acquisitions, mainly agricultural land for industrialization or infrastructure development becoming daily news it is no more acceptable that the idea of economic development is synonymous for industrialization. Our current strategy of development, which implies more economic growth along with statistically manipulated poverty lines which drawn on the basis of rupees 17 per day in rural areas(world bank report which adjusted the $1.25 per day for PPP in case of India), can not lead our country to any improvements. It seems obvious that a country with 56% of its people depending on a sector registering negative growth rate is not following the path of development under any measures of economics. Conventional economic theories recognize economic development as more important than growth. Economic development is considered as growth plus institutional changes. When we think of our country, which is categorized as “developing”, we can see the fact that our development projects are about more industries, more national income, more infra structural facilities etc. In order to ‘develop’ according to this strategy India needs more investment, to attract investment our labor laws needs to be liberalized, industry must be given importance, for which more roads, hydroelectric projects, and special tax concession zones and industrial hubs are needed. By opening up our market for global giants and letting our industrialists to compete in the global market, India is supposed to be entered the path of development. What characterized this development path is new phenomenon of farmer suicides and increased inequality. Loan waivers and special packages are failed to prevent this mass self killings. Medias no more consider these incidents as news anymore; it seems that our development strategy accepted this as a part of it. Environmental sustainability of the current development strategy is beyond questions. Our developmental theories do not have a sustainability quotient, hence while considering the contribution of some multinational cola company to ‘development’, even if the ground water tables are dangerously low, the water scarcity is severe and water pollution start affecting normal life, this matters less compared to the employment opportunities for ten or twenty people and tax income for the panchayath. If development is about reducing availability of resource first and then allowing market to fix a very high price for it in order to attain maximum income growth, then the question will change to whether we need this kind of development or not. If agrarian lands are converted into roads and SEZ s in order to promote big shopping malls where agrarian products can be bought through retail shops of foreign or domestic big capitalists at higher price then what is the development this change is bringing? Local markets and production can be more economical and can provide more income and employment opportunities for local people. Hence what is the ‘development’ in losing self sufficiency in food production or in getting high priced processed food through MNC s? What is the significance of highways and big industries if those loosing houses for this expansion are dumped in slums without alternative livelihoods? Then for whom the development is happening? If the ultimate aim of development is to improve human lives, then it can’t be at the cost of human lives. Is it like Industrialization and urbanization are the last words for development? These questions need to be answered in detail as economic development is the main weapon in the hands of policy makers. Failures in the proper understanding of development have already caused wrong orientation in the reaction of the marginalized people in the forms of regionalism and violent outcomes which can’t be neglected as law and order problems but developmental issues. Political jargon of development gets its credibility through economic theories. These necessitate an enquiry in to basic concept of development

The basic objective is to analyze the issues within the strategy of development followed now and to suggest proper changes in it. In order to do this, the basic question of what exactly is development should be considered. Recent trends in development projects show the lack of this conceptual clarity. When a new development program is considered, what determines its need and usefulness is not clear now. New social tensions in the name of development suggest that mere industrialization and income growth for competitive people can’t solve the problems we face. Idea of inclusive development as a way of including marginalized people in the process of development itself reveals the flaws in the developmental approach we have. What we are having today is just a process of industrialization, through which more income generated hence growth rate shows upward trend. This process of urbanization through industrialization is not beneficial for people, when we consider its environmental and social costs. Increased suicide rates, crime rates and health problems are indicative of the harm caused by visionless development. At the same time social tensions in the name of development and discrimination against a section people is inherent in this developmental strategy. More over the macro economic viability of this model is questionable. Increasing income for the rural mass can keep aggregate demand higher; especially for a large country like India. So a development model which avoids the domestic demand contributed by these large sections of people can’t be accepted as a wise one. Domestic market of such a populous country like India is unavoidable and the existing situation points to the need of paying attention to the majority of people who reside in the rural areas who remain unskilled. They can no more be kept under the reservation of inclusive development, who get excluded in the process of development and always happened to pay for the process of industrialization. 100 days of employment is just a small step towards ‘including’ them while farm land acquisitions and economic policies of liberlisation are excluding them in tremendous speed.