Total Pageviews

Thursday, October 18, 2012

Good morning :)

As I sit here with a cup of hot tea , missing the class today and thinking of all the sensical and nonsensical things let me make some sense..
Don't ask me why i skipped today's class...because I don't know! its  most wonderful classes I can't afford to miss..still today I just slept deciding that i am not going ..May because of the Rawlsian rekindling of thoughts i right now have..

As that idea strike again,...  is it anyone's fault that they born into a poor family? the natural circumstances or the accidental coincidence of some one born into  certain family is totally out of anyone's control ,right? That you are the daughter/son of educated, wealthy and powerful parents is not at all your virtue.. same way if you born into a family where the parents are illiterate, they live below the "drawn up" poverty line is also not your mistake.  So after attaining a level of education (as an economist am privileged to assume anything, but here let me assume people get the fundamental level of public education,as in government schools, then public university etc)if your family set up is a comfortable one to let you join first class coaching institutes , you can aspire anything. Even if it is not the family back up that support you, people aspire and achieve many things. I know students who take special tuition to children , do part time jobs and study hard to get the fellowships and hence proceed in life. But when your health prevents you from that, what is your option? when you need some tens of thousands (which is actually nominal for most of highly placed students) for your treatment, it is such an unjust situation to see such people getting stopped in their long journey of life.
Education is an equipment which will let the dispossessed to become possessed, and well equipped. I felt damn ashamed to know that one of my friends' scored really high in his higher secondary and graduation times without even having any text books with him. I the stupid, got a first rank with what not? I got the resources including books, which partly i read , wrote for the exam and the world thought she is good at her studies! He was so unprivileged that he could not wish for even a single text book because his amma had to feed his family by doing the daily wage labour. He was feeling so guilty that he is continuing his studies while his mother still do daily wage labour to make him continue his studies. And I knew many other privileged students from city who were enough equipped by their parents through all means  and still failed to make it to the central university for Msc, but he did that.

Who is meritorious? How can he be considered even a inch lesser bright compared to his classmates and friends who could get JRF and other fellowships while he was concerned about his family, the pending bank loan and suffered from another really bad health condition. haa. health is another issue. he could not do anything about such a costly( costly is such a damn relative thing! for many people the  amount won't sound really costly) treatment, even though he is suffering from it terribly. If the natural circumstances as Rawls call it were favorable for him, his treatment would have happened long back in a much easy way. When health provisions become too costly, how his fight against the current deprived situation can be improved? please, stop mentioning all the schemes your govt has. it hardly help him, its an empirical stuff i am talking about, not the crores they spend for NRHM.


Yes...my thoughts are haunting me.. what makes him less meritorious? how can you say that guy lack the skills, he made it into  PhD also in the same central university. But as Rawls said, accidental coincidences matter a lot. At the end... I feel so inferior to him.. Am I just a product of positive natural circumstances??? Even though I never got availed any special treatment during my academic career, from the 1st standard to my M phil I got the public education facilities which is equally accessible for anyone. The same State syllabus, the same malayalam medium govt. school teachers, the average ambiance of a govt. college etc. But I used to get full family support, both financially and mentally,  no burden of guilty feelings for continuing my studies, and i used to get books above all, and a good teacher's coaching for my graduation. Now I know, the projected bright students and scholars are nothing compared to those thousands of students who fail halfway due to the things beyond their control. They are the real gems..  not those products of all positive natural circumstances

2 comments:

Krishna kanth aka Kanthan said...

is it anyone's fault that they born into a poor family? the natural circumstances or the accidental coincidence of some one born into certain family is totally out of anyone's control ,right?

No, its totally under the control of their parents. So if someone is born poor we should be blaming the persons responsible for their birth.

athena said...

Do you mean to say that poor families should not have children? :) What I meant was, it is not anyone's virtue that they are born to a rich or educated family, same way someone is not responsible for the poverty into which they born. :)